INTELBRIEF

October 27, 2026

Netanyahu’s Fate Hangs in the Balance

AP Photo/David Goldman

Bottom Line Up Front

  • Benjamin Netanyahu’s long reign as prime minister could come to an end when Israeli voters go to the polls today, but Israel’s coalition-based political system introduces substantial uncertainty into the final outcome.
  • Regional events and strategic threats to Israeli security, significant factors in any Israeli election, might determine whether opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot succeeds in unseating Netanyahu.
  • The failure of the U.S.-Israeli air campaign to topple Iran’s regime has strained Netanyahu’s relations with Trump and countered his image as the candidate most able to steer U.S. policy to Israel’s benefit.
  • The October 7, 2023, Hamas attack will likely prove a pivotal factor in the election, as voters weigh Netanyahu’s forceful response against his lack of accountability for the attack.

Israeli voters go to the polls today in what will be a referendum on Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his hard-right Likud Party. Netanyahu has held his post for almost all of the period since 2009, with only a brief interruption during 2021-22. He was also prime minister during 1996-1999, having won office after a series of suicide terror attacks inside Israel by Hamas shifted the electorate sharply to the right, depriving the center-left Labor Party of what seemed a likely victory. That sudden shift in electoral fortunes illustrates the extent to which regional events and security issues – far more than domestic economic or social conditions — weigh heavily on Israeli voters. The influence of regional geopolitics on Israeli elections is far greater than it is in the United States or Western Europe.

Recent polls expect that Netanyahu will not be returned to office. Some polls show that Netanyahu’s Likud-led bloc will fall to 50-51 seats (down from 68), short of the 61 needed for a majority in the 120-seat Knesset (parliament). Opposition parties, led by former Israel Defense Forces (IDF) chief of staff Gadi Eisenkot and his newly formed Yashar party, are expected to garner 69-70 seats, according to credible polling organizations. Eisenkot, who is of Moroccan-Jewish origin, is expected to draw many votes from Israelis of Middle Eastern origin who have tended to support Netanyahu and the Likud.

Under Israel’s system, even if Eisenkot’s party finishes first, the Israeli president does not automatically task him with forming the government. The mandate goes to the lawmaker most likely to assemble a coalition capable of controlling at least 61 Knesset seats. In the past, Netanyahu has been able to assemble a governing coalition despite his Likud bloc finishing weaker than expected. Forming the next government might hinge on whether the parties supporting Eisenkot are willing to include Arab parties in a coalition. There is also a strong possibility that the election results will be inconclusive, necessitating another election in early 2027.

On domestic issues, Eisenkot supporters apparently view the vote as existential, fearing democratic erosion and what they assert is rampant corruption by Netanyahu and his cronies. Many support the opposition in order to oust far-right Netanyahu allies, including current national security minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and finance minister Bezalel Smotrich. The two have gone so far as advocating the expulsion of Palestinians from Gaza and Jewish resettlement of that territory. Of particular concern for the Arab parties (Ra’am and the Joint List), that are expected to win 13-15 seats, Smotrich has been diverting budgets from Arab-inhabited towns in Israel to communities in Israel proper. Another divisive issue is that of mandating that Orthodox Jewish males serve in the IDF.

The Israeli election is the first since the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel, and the consequences of that assault are sure to overshadow domestic issues when voters go to the polls. Analysts of Israeli opinion assess that the attack severely tarnished Netanyahu’s core image as the leader who can protect Israelis from regional anti-Israeli currents emanating from Tehran, Gaza, Lebanon, Yemen, and elsewhere. Netanyahu’s critics accuse his government of failing to detect the warning signs of the attack and of lacking preparedness to mount a response as the assault unfolded. Opposition figures advocate a formal, independent inquiry into the attack and insist that Netanyahu be held accountable. Yet some experts assess that the Hamas strike, and the series of related conflicts that emanated from it, play to Netanyahu’s strengths as willing to use hard power against Israel’s adversaries, potentially helping him overcome his drawbacks.

Yet the October 7 attack narrowed the differences among the various parties on a core issue — the establishment of an independent Palestinian state. No major contender supports that outcome now — a sharp difference from the decade after the 1993 U.S.-brokered accord between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO). In the context of that Israeli-Palestinian peace process, Israeli Labor Party and other moderate leaders supported Palestinian statehood, while Likud leaders, including Netanyahu, were opposed. There has been little disagreement with the government’s assertion that force was needed to remove Hamas as the governing and security authority in Gaza. But many Israelis view the offensive as disproportionate, which has destroyed a majority of structures in the enclave. More than 75,000 Gaza Palestinians have been killed, a figure that includes Hamas fighters — a consequence many Israelis believe has caused Israel’s global ostracism and a wave of anti-semitism. The leading opposition figures advocate adherence to the Trump peace plan for Gaza that envisions an Israeli pullout as Hamas disarms. Netanyahu’s cooperation with the Trump plan has been halting.

There are also political divisions over how to hold accountable Jewish settlers on the West Bank who have been attacking Palestinian villages and lands, as well as over the broader question of whether to annex the West Bank. Opposition figures oppose an annexation that is certain to fracture Israel’s relations with the Arab states, including those that have established diplomatic relations with Israel. Some political allies of Netanyahu support annexation, but Netanyahu, assessing the likely adverse consequences, has approached the issue with caution. Israelis are also apparently mixed on the ongoing operations against Lebanese Hezbollah, which the Netanyahu government asserts are necessary to prevent Hezbollah’s re-emergence as a strategic threat. Opposition figures generally support strict adherence to a U.S.-brokered peace plan under which the IDF is to progressively turn over captured Hezbollah positions to the Beirut government.

The Israeli election will also be influenced by two interrelated issues: the ongoing U.S.-Iran conflict, and perceptions of Netanyahu’s relations with U.S. President Donald Trump. Israeli voters weigh heavily the extent to which their leaders can secure U.S. support and assurances. Experts attribute Netanyahu’s longevity in the job, in large part, to his close relations with a succession of U.S. presidents, but particularly Trump, and his perceived ability to influence U.S. policy. However, Israeli voters recall his rift with U.S. President Barack Obama over the 2015 multilateral Iran nuclear deal (JCPOA), which Netanyahu unsuccessfully attempted to derail by cooperating with U.S. congressional Republicans opposed to that deal. Netanyahu subsequently rebuilt his influence in Washington during Trump’s first term, obtaining from him the relocation of the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem and recognition of Israel’s annexation of the Golan Heights, which the United Nations considers Syrian sovereign territory. Netanyahu’s relations with U.S. President Joe Biden were mostly positive, particularly in the wake of the October 7 attack, although Biden officials did impose some sanctions on Israel for Jewish settler attacks against Palestinians living in the West Bank.

With Trump back in the White House as of early 2025, Netanyahu’s influence in Washington was at its zenith and Netanyahu’s re-election — in a vote required by the end of 2026 — seemed assured. In June 2025, he persuaded Trump to join Israeli strikes on Iran’s nuclear sites and senior regime leaders. In late February 2026, he convinced Trump to undertake a joint air campaign that Netanyahu forecast would quickly topple the regime in Tehran. However, the remaining Iranian leaders rallied and quickly steered the U.S.-Israeli operation to a strategic dead end. By April, Trump, reportedly blaming Netanyahu for an overly optimistic campaign forecast, was actively seeking an acceptable off-ramp from the conflict, and he marginalized Netanyahu from further input.

As the Trump-Netanyahu strains grew more apparent — over the Iran war as well as Israeli resistance to winding down the ground wars in Gaza and Lebanon — Netanyahu’s political prospects in Israel faded. But Trump’s subsequent inability to reach a lasting agreement with Iran to end the conflict has provided Netanyahu with an opening to rebuild his relationship with the White House. As the Israeli election arrives, speculation in the region has intensified that Trump might ask Israel to resume strikes on Iranian leaders, in conjunction with a U.S. escalation after the November 3 midterm elections. However, a defeat for Netanyahu at the polls on Tuesday is likely to deter, or at least delay, Israel from accepting a Trump invitation to join another campaign against Iran.

SUBSCRIBE TO INTELBRIEFS